Jacksonville Team Achieves Defense Victory Through Strategic Case Management
Director Catherine Arpen and Galloway’s team in Jacksonville recently secured a favorable outcome after the Plaintiff for two separately-scheduled compulsory medical examinations (CMEs). When litigation is in the balance, Galloway delivers representation that is prepared, persistent, and professional.
Case Background
Despite numerous opportunities to comply, the Plaintiff did not attend either CME. Based on the repeated noncompliance, Arpen successfully moved for dismissal of the case. The Court agreed, bringing the litigation to an end in favor of Galloway’s client.
However, one issue remained unresolved: who would bear the cost of the missed CME appointments. The Court set an in-person evidentiary hearing to address the outstanding fees. With less than 24 hours’ notice, Galloway immediately mobilized and traveled to Miami, fully prepared to present the case.
Arpen’s approach in the hearing was straightforward through meticulous organization and credibility. Arpen and her team arrived with four fully tabbed and indexed evidence notebooks, clearly documenting:
- The scheduling of both CMEs
- The Plaintiff’s failure to appear
- The costs incurred for each missed examination
- The efforts undertaken to coordinate and confirm attendance
- All evidentiary rules noted to allow admission of the evidence.
When opposing counsel appeared without evidence to rebut, the result reflected the strength and efficacy of Galloway’s preparation and advocacy. The Court ordered:
- The Plaintiff to pay for the first missed CME
- Plaintiff’s counsel to pay for the second missed CME
- The Plaintiff to pay all attorneys’ fees and costs associated with the motion, travel, and evidentiary hearing.
The Galloway Difference in Florida
This outcome underscores a critical point: diligence and professionalism matter. Showing up prepared, especially when time is short, can make the difference between a routine hearing and a decisive victory. Galloway remains committed to delivering that level of preparation and advocacy in every case.
The Galloway team in Florida is regularly recognized for exceptional client service and responsiveness, with proactive, high-touch communication that keeps parties aligned and informed throughout the lifecycle of the matter. Firm attorneys like Catherine Arpen are strategic advocates who prioritize client outcomes by remaining well-prepared and persuasive in mediation, hearings, and negotiations.
Galloway continues to demonstrate its market-strength, regional reach, and high level of service as champions of their clients.
